However, and compared to other book adaptations that made. While benjamin is transforming, so is the social and political world around him. The curious case of benjamin button film studies essay. The film does this by making benjamins father a button manufacturer and. Benjamin s mother died after giving birth, and benjamin s father left him on the steps of a nursery home.
This odd, epic tale of a man who ages backwards is presented in an impeccable. Jul 29, 2009 like roths other screenplay, forrest gump, benjamin button covers a persons entire life and can therefore drag on a bit. In short, while ben button the movie is a love story, ben button the short story isnt. Scott fitzgerald short story, stars brad pitt as a person who is born old and ages backward.
The curious case of benjamin button summary shmoop. While the plotline is a complete different one when comparing book and film, there are however obstacles benjamin button has to overcome during his lifetime. If however, you were adamant about only taking in one or the other button rundowns, watch the movie. This story seemed to be demonstrating the unstoppable speed of life. Twelve years after his birth, he meets daisy, a child. It is instead the story of an entire lifetime, knitted together with carefully chosen anecdotes and scenes. The diary states that a man named benjamin button was born as an old man in 1918. Scott fitzgeralds story, reteams the director with brad pitt, who takes on the title role.
The curious case of benjamin button short story wikipedia. Benjamin button essay example topics and well written. The curious case of benjamin button is a short story first published in. It also was later adapted into the 2008 namesake film and in 2019 into a stage. The curious case of benjamin button quotes showing 116 of 16 for what its worth. This film is about a man named benjamin button who leads much of an ordinary life under not so ordinary circumstances. Benjamin button is born under unusual circumstances.
No comparison between benjamin button book and movie. The curious case of benjamin button differences between. Civil war is right smack at the start of benjamin s life from 18611865. Benjamin opened a book of boys stories, the boy scouts in bimini bay, and began to read. Given the condition and appearance of newborn benjamin, and the fact that his mother died during childbirth, his father, thomas jason flemyng, abandons him on the porch of a. David finchers the curious case of benjamin button, an adaptation of f. Students will analyze both the textual and film versions of the curious case of benjamin button to determine the main themes as well as to track how those. Nov 12, 2016 the movie is an adaptation of the short story written by fitzgerald. Jan 04, 2009 no comparison between benjamin button book and movie books. If one could live in reverseold to youngwould inevitable losses be erased. As i watched the film, i became consumed by a conviction that this was simply wrong.
How the curious case of benjamin button compares to the short. Could someone explain the plot of the movie the curious. Scott fitzgeralds short story about a man who ages backward. It also was later adapted into the 2008 namesake film and in 2019 into a stage musical. I hadnt heard of the fitzgerald story until my book was. I am intrigued to see this film, but i feel as if ive already read part of the plot even though it is based on an f. The curious case of benjamin button adapting literature. This might be one of the few movies that is better than the book. Outside of gatsby, however, he wrote a number of novels and short stories with the characteristic fitzgerald touch. The dying woman asks caroline to read from the diary of a friend named benjamin, whose life addresses this question. Tells the story of benjamin button, a man who starts aging backwards with consequences. The curious case of benjamin button is a splendidly made film based on a profoundly mistaken premise. Brad pitt plays a man who ages in reverse in david finchers 2008 fantasy drama the. These papers were written primarily by students and provide critical analysis of the curious case of benjamin button 2008 film, directed by david fincher.
No comparison between benjamin button book and movie books. Born under unusual circumstances, benjamin button brad pitt springs into being as an elderly man in a new orleans nursing home and ages in reverse. During the course of his life he fights in a war, falls in love, and has various other adventures. Directed by david fincher, the movie was about benjamin button, born in his eighties, starts to age backwards. The curious case of benjamin button is a short story written by f. One of the movies that have exhibited such mysteries is the curious case of benjamin button. First published in colliers magazine on may 27, 1922, it was subsequently anthologized in fitzgeralds book tales of the jazz age, which is occasionally published as the curious case of benjamin button and other jazz age stories. The curious case of benjamin button movie trailer and. The curious case of benjamin button trailer hd youtube. David fincher movie setting if all the other differences werent enough they also changed details such as, the book was set in baltimore.
But he found himself thinking persistently about the war. The film tells the life of benjamin button pitt, a man born with a rare aging. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Unlike those around him, hes born elderly and grows backwards until eventually. Over the years as benjamin got older he appeared to get younger. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 movie moviefone. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 born under unusual circumstances, benjamin button brad pitt springs into being as an elderly man in a new orleans nursing home and ages in reverse. You agonized for years over every word, each character. The story begins with a nameless, first person narrator who is ready to share with you a rather remarkable tale. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 plot summary imdb.
Watch the curious case of benjamin button movie trailers, exclusive videos, interviews from the cast, movie clips and more at. The curious case of benjamin button does not fit the classic threeact plot analysis, in which a hero commits to and then completes a difficult quest. In the movie, benjamin is born in new orleans during the victory. Scott fitzgerald was an american writer most famous for the famous 1925 novel the great gatsby. How the curious case of benjamin button compares to the. I have not watching the movie yet, i did read the story and really enjoyed it. Scott fitzgeralds short story about the baby born as an old man has got to be it. Watching it is an emotional experience, despite its meandering pace it could have should have been made leaner to make it even stronger. The curious case of benjamin button is a fantastic book, and although it only took me an hour to finish it, i felt like the length of all of those years and experiences the protagonist went through also affected me. Fitzgeralds setting is an interesting one for a story of change and incredible transformation. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 the curious. Some have opted to spend time looking for answers to their queries, while others decided to just live it without any other expectations.
What won me over to the movie and turned me off towards the book was that benjamin met his love in the movie at age 7 with him looking elderly. With time moving back, he wishes that maybe his dead son, killed in the first world war, would return home. As he lives at the home, he meets daisy, a beautiful young girl the same age. I am not particularly a fan of david fincher and his work. An analysis there are certain things in life that we cannot explain. The curious case of benjamin buttons ending explained. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 pg 2h 46m 20thcentury period pieces david fincher directs this oscarnominated tale of benjamin button, a man who was born old and wrinkled but grows younger as the years go by. His story begins in the summer of 1860, with roger button, a socially prominent man who owns a hardware company in baltimore. Dec 29, 20 the curious case of benjamin button is about living life to the fullest, but this is a movie where death is a constant reminder. Scott fitzgeralds short story about the baby born as an. The story is one of its kinds as it is about a person named benjamin button who is born with a body of a dying man in his 80s. The curious case of benjamin button page by page books.
The curious case of benjamin button revisited collider. The curious case of benjamin button film wikipedia. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading the curious case of benjamin button. An analysis of the curious case of benjamin button free. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 film questions and answers. It is an absolute masterpiece and will most definitely be one of the greatest films of all time. America had joined the allied cause during the preceding month, and benjamin wanted to enlist, but, alas, sixteen was the minimum age, and he. The confessions of max tivoli like the curious case of.
The movie is graceful, beautiful, poetic, and yet oddly distant. With brad pitt, cate blanchett, tilda swinton, julia ormond. Benjamin button, a baby that was born looking like an old man, is taken in by a nurse at an old folks home. The curious case of benjamin button and its film adaptation. Read the curious case of benjamin button by author f.
The curious case of benjamin button 2008 rotten tomatoes. Given that the curious case of benjamin button is a short story, it was only natural that the cinematic adaptation was going to add and change many details, and in the end, the film serves as an expansion of the book in some ways, and in others is a different look at the life of a man who aged in reverse. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 film summary. It is a pity that the best part of life comes at the beginning, and the worst part at the end. Feb 17, 2009 the curious case of benjamin button, a film based loosely on an f. Scott fitzgerald, one may conclude that there are more differences than there are similarities. In the book, benjamin is born a full grown old man incidentally, after this we never hear of his mother again with the mind of an old man. The basis of both the book and movie was simplistic yet versions told the fictional life story of a man living and experiencing life as he is developing physically backwards and cognitively forwards. Though it gets barely a mention in benjamin button, the u. She asks her daughter caroline to read aloud from benjamin button s diary. The curious case of benjamin button is a 2008 american fantasy romantic. The curious case of benjamin button was a near epic film in almost the same way forrest gump was. And so begins the curious case of benjamin button, adapted from the 1920s story by f. What is the meaning of the end of the curious case of.
All those around him, everyone he knows and loves, grow older in the usual way, and he passes them on the way down. The curious case of benjamin button introduction shmoop. The curious case of benjamin button begins in the hospital room of an elderly, terminally ill woman. I was surprised to find that, except for the title, lead characters name and general concept of a man aging backwards, they are almost entirely different stories. Fitzgeralds writing is a great foundation to start the story of benjamin button, and the film builds for us the rest of the house. Scott fitzgerald and the film in 2008 is quite different. Comparison between benjamin button the story and the movie. The movie the curious case of benjamin button has very little in common with the book. The whole production feels gilded as fincher made a deeply moving film out of a. Comparison between benjamin button the story and the movie after seeing the movie last week, i sought out the short story to see how they compare. Yet i strongly admired the curious case of benjamin button. The curious case of benjamin button analysis shmoop. Is the curious case of benjamin button a good movie.
The curious case of benjamin button, based on a short story by f. Benjamin button date benjamin button the movie the curious case of benjamin button is a film based on f. Nov 23, 2008 the curious case of benjamin button represents a richly satisfying serving of deepdish hollywood storytelling. The curious case of benjamin button 2008 film essays are academic essays for citation. The motivation to write that short story was from a quote by mark twain. The name is the same, and the core is the same, benjamin button is born old and as he grows older he grows younger both in the book and the movie.
Even though book and film differ in several ways, the main idea is the same and so fascinating that i decided to do my research paper on comparing the book with the movie. May 20, 2015 the curious case of benjamin button is unlike any other films ive ever seen and most probably ever will. The curious case of benjamin button american literature. The curious case of benjamin button june 25, 2014 gillian cartier hollett if ever there was a screenwriters ideal storyline on which to base their potential film, f. The question and answer section for the curious case of benjamin button 2008 film is a great resource to ask questions, find answers, and discuss the novel. Even though book and film differ in several ways, the main idea is the same and. An analysis of the curious case of benjamin button free essay.
In the movie, benjamin was left on a doorsteps of a cute black lady who ran a nursing home. Nov 16, 2008 comparison between benjamin button the story and the movie after seeing the movie last week, i sought out the short story to see how they compare. In fact, it could take pages in order to describe the movie plot. The curious case of benjamin button drama films the guardian. Therefore i wanted to find out more about it and read the short story the curious case of benjamin button by f. The curious case of benjamin button is a rarity because normal hollywoodstory adaptations lack well developed variations of the story in. The curious case of benjamin button pdf books library land.
If ever there was a screenwriters ideal storyline on which to base their potential film, f. Jan 07, 2009 the curious case of benjamin button is a fantastic book, and although it only took me an hour to finish it, i felt like the length of all of those years and experiences the protagonist went through also affected me. I should probably watch the movie and see the differences. In the book mainly because of the nonacceptance of society and in the movie because of. What won me over to the movie and turned me off towards the book was that benjamin met his love in the movie. In the film, benjamin is born to the button family, who own a company that makes buttons of course.
809 450 323 616 1190 1374 85 1403 1432 1466 1132 1309 648 1494 1277 251 814 513 306 275 1312 572 74 1393 1105 1192 192 1215 1145 1101 778 463 1437 1474 1009 1343 852 667 1059 608 580 1419 872 890 438 41 357 1067